Why The Knicks Are Better Off If Carmelo Leaves

04.11.14 4 years ago
Carmelo Anthony

Carmelo Anthony (Steve Mitchell/USA TODAY Sports)

The New York Knicks have been the most disappointing team in the NBA this year, sitting in ninth place in the Eastern Conference at 33-45. Last season the Knicks finished second in the East, winning 54 games and reached the Eastern Conference Semifinals before falling to Indiana. However, a lot has changed in one season. Mike Woodson is most likely on his way out at the end of the year whether the Knicks sneak into the playoffs or not, and Carmelo Anthony’s decision to test free agency at the end of the year has caused distractions for the team throughout the season.

New York Knicks owner James Dolan went out and brought in the great Phil Jackson to try and turn the Knicks back into a winning organization. Many see the signing of Jackson as a tactic to convince Carmelo Anthony to stay in New York, but is Anthony staying the best decision for the future? Yes, Carmelo Anthony is in the prime of his career and has had a fantastic season to follow up on his NBA scoring title last year. Anthony is averaging 27.5 points per game and is averaging a career-high in rebounds per game with 8.2. His 40.4 three-point shooting percentage is the second-highest in his career and he is playing 38 minutes a night (another career-high). But if he opts to take his talents elsewhere, the Knicks may be better off.

[RELATED: J.R. Smith looks like one of the East’s best scorers again]

If Anthony returns to the Big Apple, the team won’t be much different next season. Amar’e Stoudemire, Andrea Bargnani and Tyson Chandler are all back next year, along with J.R. Smith and Raymond Felton. This leaves the Knicks with almost zero cap space and they are without a pick in the upcoming NBA Draft this summer. Anthony knows he won’t be winning a title with the same roster he currently has to play with, making next season look hopeless already. Anthony would have to wait until the 2015-2016 season to be paired up with another superstar in order to have a chance to win an NBA title.

If Anthony leaves and signs elsewhere, Phil Jackson will have to wait just one season to have a clean slate where he can then rebuild the culture of the organization. Stoudemire, Bargnani and Chandler will all be free agents in 2015 and Felton and Smith will have player options in 2015. Although I am against tanking the season if Anthony doesn’t return, it seems like the best move for the organization. The Knicks can tank the season to get a high draft pick, trade away some of the players listed above and convince Felton and Smith to opt out because they are not a part of the future.

The New York Knicks would then be in a great position to rebuild the team with some young rising stars. Iman Shumpert and Tim Hardaway Jr. would be the only two remaining players on the Knicks roster at the start of the 2015 free agency period, leaving the Knicks with a ton of cap space. The Knicks would then have enough money to go after some big names in free agency.

Kevin Love and LaMarcus Aldridge are both free agents in the summer of 2015 and the Knicks could use a big man to replace Chandler down low. Kyrie Irving, Rajon Rondo and Kemba Walker are free agents in 2015 as well and the Knicks desperately need a point guard. If Phil Jackson can lure Love away from the West Coast and bring Irving close to his home in New Jersey, the Knicks would have one of the best young combinations in the league. Love (25 years old) and Irving (22) would leave the Knicks with a bright future and make the Knicks an immediate title contender.

The Knicks can add some players around the two as well. Other free agents in 2015 that could be on the Knicks radar include:

-Klay Thompson
-Jeremy Lamb
-Jeff Green
-Jimmy Butler
-Kawhi Leonard
-Kenneth Faried
-Terrence Jones
-Brook Lopez

Keep reading for more on why tanking is the best option…

Around The Web