Who Made The Better Catch, Pirates Catcher Tony Sanchez Or This Random Old Lady

Cleveland Indians old lady catch

Earlier this week we asked you, the With Leather readership, to determine who’d MASSIVELY SUPLEXED it better: sumo monster Byamba or New York Jets CB Ellis Lankster. Over 64% of you chose Byamba ragdolling a 400 pound dude named “MAN OF FAT STEEL” over Lankster’s german-into-an-ura-nage, so I thought I’d get your opinion on this.

Who had yesterday’s best MLB Wild Card-related catch? Was it Pittsburgh Pirates catcher Dirty “Tony” Sanchez going over the rail and toppling into the dugout, or was it … uh, this lady? She’s from Cleveland. More on her in a sec.

Here’s the Sanchez catch.

That’s an amazing catch, right? A Catch of the Year candidate for sure. An easy win for Sanchez.


Yes folks, a mild-mannered woman who may or may not be Martha Plimpton attended the Astros/Windians game at Progressive Field and went home with no only a souvenir, but never-ending temporary praise from the Internet.

So, you make the call. Who had the better catch? Let us know who you picked in the comments section below.

Around The Web