The Best And Worst Of WWE NXT 9/18/13: The One Where Tyler Breeze Tags Out

Pre-show notes:

Likes, comments and shares are appreciated. Spreading the love of NXT is important. Your finger making a slight motion over the “like” button helps it (and the people who write about it) out tremendously.

Here’s a link to this week’s show. I encourage you to watch it before reading the column, because you should ALWAYS watch NXT.

– Follow us on Twitter @withleather, follow me personally @MrBrandonStroud and like us on Facebook.

– The Bo Dallas hotline can be reached at 1-900-909-9900. Kids, get your parents’ permission before calling.

And now, the Best and Worst of WWE NXT for September 18, 2013.

Best: Comparing The First Sami Zayn/Curt Hawkins Match To The Second One

The very first edition of The Best And Worst Of NXT, back in the long long ago when Renee Young wore her hair down and Tyler Breeze was just a gleam in Mike Dalton’s eye, luckily coincided with the debut of Sami Zayn in a match against former tag team champion Curt Hawkins. The match was built around the idea that Hawkins was an established, proven talent, and that Sami Zayn was gonna have to prove himself despite a decade of international accolades in the minor leagues. Zayn won the match with a tornado DDT off the ropes, got into a beef with Antonio Cesaro in the next segment, and history was underway.

Fast forward four months. This week’s episode of NXT begins with a rematch between Zayn and Hawkins … only now Zayn is a guy who can get Match Of The Year contenders out of actually established WWE Superstars, a guy absolutely on his way to becoming the next NXT Champion, and the idea of him losing to a guy like Curt Hawkins is absurd. The match ends with a tornado DDT off the ropes, just like before.

NXT has a shaky history because it is effectively still a wrestling school, and sometimes characters change or get absorbed or just disappear and you have to roll with it. At the same time, they aren’t afraid to embrace the history they’re allowed to remember and let it enhance what’s happening now, so Zayn/Hawkins II becomes an important moment in the evolution of Zayn’s character as we know it. He’s always had the talent and the confidence, but now he’s got the momentum and wins to back it up, totally independent — pardon the pun — of his pre-WWE days. The crowd forgets to chant “ole ole ole” sometimes now because they’re too busy chanting “Sami.” Progress.

Worst: The “Main Rostered Talent” Talking Point

That all said, Curt Hawkins is not Antonio Cesaro or Jack Swagger. A great Curt Hawkins match still isn’t all that great, and it’s funny how the roles have been reversed … in the previous match, it was Zayn looking to debut and impress the WWE Universe. Here, it’s almost like Hawkins is being thrown in there to see if he can hang and get the same magical results as Cesaro and Swagger, to sorta justify him still getting to be around.

Bo Dallas brings it up a little later, but who gives a shit about Curt Hawkins? Riley and what’s-his-face can bring up how Hawkins is “main rostered talent” all they want, but that’s meaningless. NXT has grown out of that. Guys like Zayn shouldn’t have to be intimidated when they come across guys like Hawkins or Yoshi Tatsu or JTG because Jesus Christ, those guys NEVER win. They’re around to fill up the ring during battle royals on tours. They aren’t succeeding or making it. Those are the guys who get obliterated and replaced by the ones who can’t help BUT make it, and if that boot to the mush and tornado DDT were the last we ever saw of Curt Hawkins, who’d miss him? Who’d miss his cane?

Seriously though, what happened to his cane? Did Bray Wyatt beat it up and kidnap it?

Best: Aiden English Becomes The Heel Tyler Breeze Accidentally Isn’t

Remember when Tyler Breeze debuted? He was supposed to get booed because he’s an arrogant male model, but WWE didn’t realize that Zoolander was the HERO of his story, not the villain, and within two weeks Breeze was getting “that was awesome” chants for doing practically nothing. Some guys get to be the villain, and some guys are just too likable to stay it, stupid gimmick or no. Damien Sandow’s like that. They have to neuter him and keep him losing 2-minute matches in silence or he’ll catch fire and ruin their thing.

I think Aiden English will work well as the Working Tyler Breeze. If you haven’t seen the show and are afraid to click that video because of the thumbnail, English is doing this thing where he’s an “entertainer,” meaning he sings parody show-tunes about how great he is as he walks to the ring. He demands a spotlight, first politely, then sternly. He easily wins his match and performs an encore. The crowd boos him as much as they can and I hope that keeps going, because (1) you really SHOULD boo a guy for doing this, and (2) Alex Riley though it was funny, and we should try hard to never agree with Alex Riley.

Best: The Bo Dallas Hotline

And now, Bo Dallas continues to become my favorite WWE character.

Renee Young tries to ask Bo Dallas a question, but he’s busy recording a message to his Bo-lievers via the BO DALLAS HOTLINE, a Bo Dallas information, news and gossip resource Bo is personally running in places like BO-LIVIA because PUNS ARE MORE IMPORTANT TO HIM THAT FINANCIAL REASON. He drops some truth on Renee about how beating Curt Hawkins isn’t that big of a deal (truth), how Sami needs to beat someone credible before he can get a title shot (also truth … he lost to both Cesaro AND Swagger) and has an idea for a title opportunity, but can’t expound on it because he’s got to attend a ribbon. cutting. ceremony. (said just like that)

By the end Renee is facepalming, the perfect mixture of “THIS f*cking guy” and “I love this f*cking guy.” As Bray Wyatt becomes an afterthought on Raw, Bo Dallas suddenly becomes a wrestling genius. Can we divide the Rotunda Success Gene between the two of them evenly at some point?

Worst: Next Week, TRIPLE H



Worst: CJ, You A Busta

The second half of the show was the main-event, an 8-man tag team match pitting Tyler Breeze, the Ascension and Leo Kruger against Team Never Gonna Make It, aka “the babyfaces on this show who aren’t Sami Zayn.” You probably gathered that from the header image. Hulu put up a clip from the match, but it’s the less interesting part:

Here are a few things I didn’t enjoy about it:

1. Seriously, NXT has a lot of enjoyable bad guys and almost nobody “good” I can sincerely cheer. Zayn is remarkable, but he’s off in his own universe. The CM Punk of NXT, the guy who gets to have his own storyline while everyone else “unites.” I know they’re more interested in him doing burpees than getting over, but Kassius Ohno needs to come back with THE QUICKNESS. And maybe bring Solomon Crowe with him.

2. I’m not alone in thinking this. Listen to the crowd’s reaction during the match. They spend the entirety of it wishing Tyler Breeze would get into the ring (more on that in a second) and giving those good guys not much more than polite applause. Neville’s finish gets a nice reaction because it always does, but it has Neville attached to it so nobody cares until he starts balancing on the top rope. Corey Graves continues to wrestling in jeggings and blow. Bo Dallas already got turned heel by the crowd, let’s no turn EVERYBODY into Bo Dallas.

3. I ranted on Xavier Woods a lot last week, but man, “Lost In The Woods” is the dumbest finisher on the show. He has to wait until you’re kneeling, hit the ropes, then sorta slide under your arm and do a reverse STO. So basically you’re falling from a very short distance and you’re protected by his entire arm landing under you. Oh and he calls it f*cking “Lost In The Woods” because his last name is “Woods.” If you saw the latest promo school videos, he’s trying out a “see ya, WOODSn’t wanna be ya!” catchphrase. The guy already has “90s pop culture guy,” “dancing WWE black guy” and “getting a PhD” gimmicks. Does he need CAN’T STOP WORDPLAYIN’ WITH MY SURNAME on top of it?

4. CJ Parker is like I watched a bad wrestling match and it came to life as a sentient smoke creature, like when that kid tries cigarettes in Cartoon All-Stars To The Rescue. Can Garfield and the Ninja Turtles show up and help me get rid of him? Is that what Xavier Woods is trying to do?

5. just tag in Breeze already

Best: Tyler Breeze, Cowardly Heel And SUPER FACE

Tyler Breeze is the man.

If you’re watching the full show on Hulu, skip to the end of the last commercial break and listen to the crowd. They spend 100% of the time anybody other than Breeze is in the ring chanting stuff like, “TAG IN BREEZE,” “WE WANT TYLER” or simply “BREEZE! BREEZE! BREEZE! BREEZE!” He milks it, too, sitting on the ring apron watching Team Never Gonna Make It apply armbar after armbar, and then BOOM he tags himself in and the crowd ERUPTS. He does ABSOLUTELY NOTHING, gets punched once and TAGS RIGHT THE HELL BACK OUT. For not the first time in his short career, Tyler Breeze gets a “that was awesome” chant for doing nothing but existing fully-formed.

How are you supposed to boo him? NXT’s crowd is less about a large group of peoples’ stimulus response to good vs. evil stories and more of a celebration of new WWE Superstars who are doing something right, and Tyler is doing everything right. The fact that he’s barely done anything since his debut is part of his charm. Like I said, Zoolander is the hero of his story. He’s vain and stupid, but dammit, he’s our guy. The fact that the tag-ins and tag-outs were building toward the finish of the match and not just an asinine thing he was doing to get himself over makes it that much better.

Worst: “this Face Finisher sequence is the most depressing thing I’ve ever seen”

I urge you to get an NXT friend. You know, someone else who watches the show regularly you can chat with about it, because hey, there really aren’t that many of us. My NXT friend is David D. from The Smoking Section, and asking him about shit like this is my favorite. The emboldened words are his response to the finish of the match, wherein Tyler Breeze tries to pull his tag in/get punched/bail gag one too many times and gets ditched by his teammates, leaving him alone to get hit by everybody’s finishers and lose. And OH MY GOD they are the saddest finishers. CJ Parker’s finish is a slap, which is not gonna work unless he’s dropping the hippie gimmick to be Jushin Thunder Liger, and Corey Graves somehow manages to top that by DOING A SHOULDERBLOCK TO THE THIGH. Who are you, greaser Mongo? I HATE YOU, COREY GRAVES.

Anyway, on top of that, this was David’s opinion of the match.

Fake CM Punk and Nakoa-Wolf Manakauapo Namakaeha Momoa on the same apron with the 90s Black guy is the most TNA that a WWE match has ever looked

He managed to burn Impact and Lisa Bonet in the same sentence. NXT friends are the best.