Watch Amy Poehler And Billy Eichner Hilariously Scream At Star-Struck Strangers To Sing Christmas Carols

Billy Eichner popped in during Jimmy Kimmel‘s monologue last night to bestow quite a gift upon the world: a special holiday-themed Billy on the Street segment in which he and the eternally perfect Amy Poehler sprint around the streets of New York trying to engage strangers in Christmas carols.

Come for the awkward moments and star-struck expressions; stay for the normally delightful Poehler’s over-the-top freakout at a man who dares to say he doesn’t know who she is. “YOU KNOW ME!”

Jimmy Kimmel Live