10 170 points After Hours The Weeknd, Republic Records Critics who voted for this album Candace McDuffie 1 Gregory Castel 1 Joshua Kellem 1 Eric Diep 2 Jarred Howard 2 Jarret Myer 2 Jem Aswad 2 Alex Frank 3 Bianca Gracie 3 Derrick Rossignol 3 Corbin Reiff 4 Rachel Brodsky 4 Brittany Menjivar 5 Larisha Paul 5 Richard Trapunski 5 Trace William Cowen 5 Kenneth Partridge 6 Hannah Giorgis 7 Kent Wolgamott 7 Kirsten Spruch 7 Kristen S. Hé 7 Spencer Patterson 7 Vanessa Franko 7 Alex Suskind 8 Erica Campbell 8 Jackie Reed 8 Kyle McGovern 8 Patrick Lyons 10