31 71 points Bonny Light Horseman Bonny Light Horseman, 37d03d Critics who voted for this album Grayson Haver Currin 1 Stephen Deusner 1 Jeremy Shatan 2 Davy Jones 5 Andrew Sacher 6 Josh Modell 6 Kate Flynn 6 Mike Ayers 6 Spencer Kornhaber 6 Ellen Johnson 7 Jerry Cowgill 7 Eric R Danton 8