12 144 points Midnights Taylor Swift Critics who voted for this Cherise Johnson 1 Ilana Kaplan 1 Lexi Lane 1 Megan Armstrong 1 Melissa Locker 1 Giselle Libby 2 Kelsey Barnes 2 Patrick Crowley 2 Jeff Benjamin 3 Nina Braca 3 Dominique Moreno 4 Mikael Wood 4 P. Claire Dodson 4 Dan Caffrey 5 Stephen Thompson 5 Kristen S. Hé 6 Kenneth Partridge 7 DC Hendrix 9 Kayleigh Hughes 9 Annie Zaleski 10 Caitlin White 10 Craig Manning 10 Jael Goldfine 10 Mike Ayers 10
