The internet has been a precarious place for me lately. I’ve noticed that the lifespan for visibility is the same no matter how small or big your platform: Exalt the person, crucify the person, and raise the person up again. Continue this until death, or simply until someone seemingly more interesting and younger comes along. The unique part is how some personalities are characterized as they are crucified, which tends to depend on their social identities. Femmes and women who are Black and of color are often vilified at a much more rapid and heinous pace than those who occupy other identities.
This has been true throughout pop culture history: Yoko Ono was blamed for the demise of the world’s favorite and most influential band, The Beatles. She was seen as a wicked woman that used her sexuality and feminine brand of cunning to disband four incredibly powerful and talented white men. In more modern times, before Beyonce was globally loved, she was globally demonized. She was painted as a villain that — in a similar vein to the plot of Dreamgirls — destroyed the lives of her musical sisters in order to arrive at stardom.
The response to this type of demonization is usually to behave your way out of the criticism; be nice, be quiet, be likable and hopefully, the public will take you back. The image of the Black woman or femme holding their breath to be loved again by the public is not a new one. Consider the story of how Eartha Kitt was blackballed by Hollywood after sharing her critical opinion on the Vietnam war with President Johnson and the First Lady. Kitt was forced to live in Europe to sustain her livelihood until she was finally embraced again, emblematic of a type of Black Hollywood legend about what can happen not just your fame, but to your livelihood if the powers that be decide you’re too much of a wicked person to work.
Nicki Minaj is the latest Black female entertainer to have a difficult time in the public eye. It’s hard to tell exactly when her wave of popularity went from mostly favorable to unfavorable, but the peak was undoubtedly Remy Ma’s diss track, “Shether,” which had an image of a bloody and dismembered Nicki Minaj as the single cover. From that point on, Nicki Minaj has held a questionable place in the public imagination, although she still maintains the massive “Barbz” fanbase that she’s cultivated since the beginning of her career.
Recently, we’ve seen artists like Lady Gaga and Taylor Swift swing from being immensely popular and likable to widely criticized — if still popular — artists in the timespan of a single album cycle. Like those two, at their lowest points, Nicki’s next step was going to determine if she still had as tight a grip on the public as she once had, and the outcome hinged on how she decided to handle her new public persona as the villain.