Should Rocketman have aspired to land like Bohemian Rhapsody? That’s an embarrassingly loaded question, but here I am, tossing it out there. On one hand, the Queen biopic was a financially astounding hit, and Rami Malek walked away with a Best Actor Oscar for what many but not all feel was a deserving performance as Freddie Mercury. However, the editing was a mess but also earned an Oscar, and Brian May and Roger Taylor’s input may have led to the film’s arguably sanitized tone and downplaying of Freddie’s sexuality within the larger story. It’s safe to say that Rocketman — the “musical fantasy”-not-a-biopic about Elton John starring Taron Egerton — would love to score those box-office dollars while edging out BoRhap with more critical acclaim.
From the looks of the responses to CinemaCon footage of the movie (directed by Dexter Fletcher, who took over Bohemian Rhapsody‘s final leg after Bryan Singer was fired) the movie might succeed on both fronts. Uproxx’s Mike Ryan believes that Rocketman will make buckets and buckets of money.
My take on the ROCKETMAN footage is ROCKETMAN will make a lot of money.
— Mike Ryan (@mikeryan) April 4, 2019
Other takes on the footage point toward a refreshingly unadulterated air — that is, an R-rated approach to celebrating the success of a beloved artist — which earned enormous applause on Thursday.
Just saw an extended trailer for #Rocketman and it gave a better picture into their approach to bringing Elton John’s story to life. Looks very “Bohemian Rhapsody” in that way, but certainly with an R-rating. Nice to see these biopics celebrating the artists we love #CinemaCon
— JoBlo.com (@joblocom) April 4, 2019
https://twitter.com/katerbland/status/1113856385144385541
Other reactions zero in on the almost guaranteed box-office success here, along with all kinds of praise for Egergon, who did his own singing.
ROCKETMAN is going to absolutely slay at the box office. It's gonna be maje. #CinemaCon
— Amy Kaufman (@AmyKinLA) April 4, 2019
https://twitter.com/ScottWamplerBMD/status/1113856347064287233
Extended look at #Rocketman. @TaronEgerton is the real deal – he sounds freaking amazing as Elton John. Deeply into this. #CinemaCon
— @alishagrauso.bsky.social (@AlishaGrauso) April 4, 2019
.@ParamountPics just showed a very long sizzle reel from #Rocketman and WOW. @TaronEgerton looks brilliant in the role and the scale and scope looks huge. Remember director @Dexfletch was the one that finished #BohemianRhapsody after Singer was fired and he helms this film. pic.twitter.com/bJziR7mZQh
— Steven Weintraub (@colliderfrosty) April 4, 2019
Notably, Egerton spoke out about the “fairly hands-off” approach of Elton John during the making of this film.
Extended look at #Rocketman. @TaronEgerton is the real deal – he sounds freaking amazing as Elton John. Deeply into this. #CinemaCon
— @alishagrauso.bsky.social (@AlishaGrauso) April 4, 2019
Taron Egerton – who does all his own singing – says Elton John was fairly hands-off and was happy for them to have tun with him and reinvent him. #Rocketman #CinemaCon
— @alishagrauso.bsky.social (@AlishaGrauso) April 4, 2019
And the comparisons to Bohemian Rhapsody probably won’t stop, with a few folks on the fence on whether Rocketman is distinctly different or too much like its immediate predecessor.
An extended look at #RocketMan leans into the R-rating w/ colorful language and fantastical musical moments for Elton John’s Saturday Night’s Alright at a carousel and Rocketman at the bottom of a swimming pool, distinctly selling itself as different from Bohemian Rhapsody. pic.twitter.com/uZbq1Z0fAk
— Fandango (@Fandango) April 4, 2019
Saw about 7 minutes of #Rocketman footage. Looked pretty good when it doesn’t look like Bohemian Rhapsody. It looked like Bohemian Rhapsody about half the time. #CinemaCon
— Angie J. Han (@ajhan) April 4, 2019
Rocketman floats into theaters on May 31.