Since the 11-person comedy troupe The State found cult stardom on MTV in the early ’90s, Michael Showalter has been a comedy fixture, and one who’s played a lot of different parts both in front of and behind the scenes. When The State, ran its course, Michael Showalter moved on to a series of other shows, films, and various comedy projects, sometimes working with frequent collaborators, and sometimes on his own. He co-created Wet Hot American Summer, became, with Michael Ian Black and David Wain, one-third of the beloved “Stella” comedy team, and eventually found his way behind the camera, making his feature directorial debut with The Baxter in 2005, a film in which he also played the lead. The Baxter was Showalter’s first foray into a genre he had long admired: the romantic comedy. He would later satirize and send up rom-coms with 2014’s They Came Together, but when he directed the acclaimed Hello, My Name is Doris, it once again became clear that he had deep respect for the genre.
Showalter’s most recent film is The Big Sick, is a semi-autobiographical romantic comedy starring Kumail Nanjiani and co-written by Nanjiani and Emily Gordon. The film is earning Showalter a whole new round of accolades, and I was pleased to get a chance to sit down with him to pick his brain about romantic comedies, what he’s learned as a director by making three of them, and what’s next for Stella, Wet Hot American Summer, and Showalter himself.
You’ve spoken before about how The Big Sick plays around with the structure of the romantic comedy, and how the second act is different than other romantic comedies. Do you want to speak a little bit about how you, Kumail, and co-writer Emily Gordon have played around with the structure of the typical romantic comedy?
Well, I mean, in a typical romantic comedy, the second act of the movie would normally be where the two characters fall in love, and that’s where you see them really get to know each other, and it’s where the audience gets to really invest in the relationship, and in a normal movie, you don’t want to see them breaking up until closer to the end of the movie, and then you’re going, “Oh no! I want them to get back together!”
So, [here] we had to sort of squeeze an entire movie’s worth of a relationship into the first act. And, the reason we needed to do that was so the audience felt… We need to really get to know Emily by the end of the first act of the movie, so that when she goes into the coma, we feel the loss of her. We feel like we know her, we feel like we miss her, we feel like we know what their relationship is and how strong their connection is, how unique it is. And so, again, in a typical movie of this nature, they would’ve only met a few times and gone on a date [by the end of the first act], and had one or two conversations or something, and so … Then you have to figure out, well now we have an entire act’s worth of the movie, where she’s not there anymore, this character that we’ve gotten to know so well. So how’s that gonna work? It’s just a lot of… blueprinting that goes into figuring out what the mechanics of that are.
Even though, to a certain extent, the story tells itself, there are a lot of moments along the way where you could go in the wrong direction, and I’m a big believer of the idea that the audience can be deeply affected by one false move. One false move can lose the audience for 15 minutes or something. One little thing that takes you out of the story, or points you in the wrong direction can have a really big effect on everything. There’s just a lot of calibration going on, for me anyway, to get it so that we remind you of here at the right moment, and maybe we let you forget about her for a little while… All these little things that go on behind the scenes so that audience is going along with the story in the way that we would like them to.
You’ve had three romantic comedies. What were the things that you’ve learned from The Baxter, to Hello, My Name is Doris, to The Big Sick, that have informed you as a director?