
David Pemberton
I was introduced to Magic: The Gathering by David Bowie. I’d moved back to Denver after college to find that most of my friends from high school had grown up and left town. I was lonely, depressed, and — even worse — bored. I spent my evenings stumbling from bar to bar, trying to wedge myself into social situations, still unsure of how an adult makes new friends. It was a trying time, but one that taught me a great deal of self-reliance and fearlessness. It led me to do crazy, dangerous things. Things I would have never imagined myself capable of. Like karaoke.
“Next up, David Pimburton!” the DJ announced. She stared down at the slip of paper in mild confusion, realizing that she’d mispronounced my last name.
“It’s Pemberton!” I yelled from the crowd, like a ‘that guy’, sauntering forward with a can of Tecate clutched in my fist. I climbed on stage, took the mic, and waited for the music to start playing.
“It’s a god-awful small affair,” I crooned, adopting my best ironic British accent, slurring my way through the first bars. It was a sloppy rendition of Bowie’s “Life on Mars?” If I’m honest, the best thing about singing David Bowie at Karaoke is that his songs are often best when shouted — the one volume that drunks can manage — in unison with the audience. On stage, I could feel the pulse of the crowd waiting for their turn to sing.
“Is there life on Maaaaaaaaaaaars?” A few people applauded, not at my voice (which is terrible), but at the joy of singing along to David Bowie. His music has a mystical way of bringing people together.
“That was really great!” yelled a tall, thin boy with long hair and thick sideburns. “But that’s the song I was going to sing. Now I’ve got to find something else.” He bought me a drink and introduced me to his wife, Pallas. “I’m Matt,” he said, shaking my hand.
The combination of booze and Bowie led us into deep conversation, and at the end of the night, I wondered if Matt and I might be friends. Like I said, these lonely nights often led me to do strange things, including, in this instance, passing my number to a boy.
“I know it’s weird,” I yelled, as someone on stage bludgeoned Billy Joel’s ‘Piano Man.’ “But we should all hang out sometime!”
I woke up the next morning smelling like salt and yeast, the telltale odor of a long night that would soon be accompanied by a massive hangover. This was something I was becoming accustomed to — the booze, the fuzzy memory, and the miserable day-after. I left my apartment (which I hated) and got in my car (which I hated) and drove to my job (which I hated). I spent the morning drinking black coffee, trying to wash away the metallic taste of a night spent drinking. Around lunchtime, I received a text message from an unknown number.
I never played any of those types of card games, but I always just assumed that whomever put the most money in building their deck would win more often than not. Poker seems more fair
Poker MAY be more fair, but the idea is that you can get creative with how you build a deck. There are decks that I’ve played with that cost $20 that beat decks that cosr $200, it just depends. Also, for the most part, I play non-competitively, which means no one I play with spends a ton of money on it.
Magic can be a bit like that– which is why I don’t play it anymore– but honestly, there’re lots of other games that strive to eliminate that concern…Starting you with the same cards/having you build decks as a part of the game, for instance. If that’s your reason for disinterest, you might find games like Dominion(random example) a pleasant surprise.
@Wordweary Ah Dominion is a blast! Have you ever tried Boss Monster? A bit different but still a lot of fun.
@David Pemberton I have not! These days, I mostly either a) play a RPG with my long-standing gaming group who, despite having scattered across the country, still do Mondays virtually or b) play something with the kids. Recently, b = a lot of Pokemon(which isn’t as soul crushing as I’d feared) and Sushi Go! That said, I occasionally still get pulled into game nights with a broader group that likes to try new ones basically every session…I’ll bring it up. Thanks for the recommendation.
You can also rent actual decks at tournaments as well. Though I still find myself getting sexually aroused by playing a Black Lotus in vintage tourneys.
I played Magic “back in the day” and burned out on that particular game, but games, in general, remain a thing I do. I don’t quite get people who need to box or judge other people by one pursuit. So yeah, I play Dungeons and Dragons on Monday…I also am pretty connected to the local music scene here. Aaand I’ve got a big boy job. None of these things are opposed to each other, and all of them make me a happier camper.
All this is to say– I don’t get why being disaffected and unengaged is a thing adults do. Nerdery is where the fun is anyway– good for you in letting go of your reservations.
100% agree. Literally all of our pursuits are equally trivial (“he’s a nihilist, dude”). The idea that caring about smoked salt or basketball or cars is somehow better than magic or juggling or vintage unicycles is idiotic in my thinking.
Oh, my friend Matt taught me to play DnD as well. I am obsessed now, nothing is more fun than pretending to be a half-elf with my friends. Have you ever checked out the podcast The Adventrue Zone?
@Steve Bramucci Exactly, although vintage unicycles seems like it might well be right in the wheelhouse for the mustachioed hipsters above…”Why must these bike racks support only the superficial second wheel?” they might bemoan…I digress.
@David Pemberton I have not– I will check it out. Yeah, RPGs are good fun with the right folks…We’re getting ready to try Eclipse Phase, because who doesn’t want to play a body-hopping uplifted squid IN SPACE? <– as implied, Eclipse Phase specifically checks a lot of nerdlist boxes.
I played Magic when I was in elementary school, and always enjoyed it, but gradually stopped playing because 1) my friends mostly stopped, and 2) I didn’t have the money to invest into new cards.
Now that I’m older, I would love to start playing again, but…I don’t know anybody around me that I could play against. My wife’s brother plays, but he lives several states away. Learning D&D would be fun, too, but similar issues – lack of company to play with.
Finding new people to play with is the hardest part, especially if you don’t play competitively. That said, getting into the game now isn’t TOO expensive (you can buy a starter deck for $15), but it gets pricey when you’re playing with people who dump money into it.
My local comic/card shop has about 10 card tables set up for people to play various games. I bet if I asked them I could find a group of people to play with – not sure what your city is like, but they may have something similar.
@Tronner- Same. My LCS seems to be heavily reliant on its CCG business, Magic especially. Whenever I go in looking for blank sketch covers, there’s always gaming stuff going on, whether it be people playing or talking shop, or stopping in to sign up for the next tournament. It never fails. They even have occasional days where you can come in and learn the game, free of charge. Their bonus freebies on Free Comic Book Day were all cardstuffs too (lil random loose packs of various games and a Magic starter deck). I imagine any shop with a decent gaming presence is similarly newcomer-friendly.
Wait, people at a bar were giving you shade for playing a card game? What fresh hell is that!
Then again maybe it’s just more common to see card games, or games in general at bars in the PNW.
It is in the PNW, I’d argue, but also MTG is a pretty space-consuming game. Like, we took up an entire table with all our lands, creatures, and enchantments. Oh, and MULTIPLE 20 sided die.
I recently discovered the mtg app in the playstore. I kind of prefer not having to play socially now, and it’s alot cheaper.
I think it’s the social aspect that sells it for me
I was not a “back-in-the-day”-er. Magic was something that came and went by the time I started playing. That’s not to say it’s dead, just that it’s peak was at a point in my life where I was between groups of friends. I’d left behind a group of Paper RPG players and after a protracted lull (and many lonely days) I fell in with a group at my new job, who were… Paper RPG players. They were active during the MTG boom and so they all had decks and huge backlogs of cards.
.
Even among them there were a couple that didn’t play and resisted so they usually didn’t break it out at gaming days. But then they ran a draft tournament so i got in, knowing nothing about how to construct a deck, and pretty much finished last. But that didn’t mean it wasn’t fun.
.
That lead to playing online as one had a server dedicated to running the game. My work friends had moved on to other jobs, but they were still my friends so Lunch at work meant connecting online and playing for an hour.
.
These days i get to play maybe once a year when there’s a weekend where no other games are going on. We usually play with decks from the old house tournaments so we know we’re fairly matched.
I love that you played MTG. I never got into it, was more of a comic book guy at the time and spent most of my fun money on that, but I was always sort of drawn to the guys at the comic shop that were playing. Right now I play DnD (5e) almost every weekend. It’s just an excuse for me to drink my weight in Mountain Dew and hang with my friends – and yeah, totally nerd out on beating a lich with a rag tag band of adventurers. My wife calls it Orcs and Dorks and is perplexed at the fun I have, but I don’t understand adult coloring books so we’re about even.
Imagine a DnD themed adult coloring book. You would be so happy together.
It isn’t DnD, but I have a FB artist friend that sells fantasy themed coloring sheets and has a full coloring book on the way soon.
@Tronner Has she seen the AD&D coloring book?
@wordweary That’s perfect! Maybe I should get some colored pencils and have some quality coloring time with her.
@TheNME That’s pretty cool. As with the DND coloring book I’d probably really get into coloring up a dragon or mace-wielding barbarian.
@Tronner Cool! I had(have? it’s probably somewhere) a copy of that when I was wee. Some of the classic modules also have similar art in black and white as well…There’re probably images. Try “The Tomb of Horrors” as an example.
Glad you found your thing and finally embraced your inner geek, David. Also, your art is even more on-point than usual in this article. Excellent work.
CCGs (and DnD-type stuff) are the one really gaping hole in my nerd game. Sports cards have always taken up most of my very limited funtime funds, with comics, anime/manga, video games, action figures, and in my adult life, art supplies, all vying for the little that’s left. I’m not much for social interaction and absolutely suuuck at picking up on the nuances of detail-oriented things anyway, so it might be for the best.
I agree on the sports cards taking up a hole that Magic could have filled. I think sports cards actually started getting a lot more fun in the 1990s when they really started pushing the short prints, relics, and autographs. I could see myself having gotten lost in Magic just for the collectors side of it. Now I have bankers boxes – full of smaller boxes – full of cards, detritus of me trying to find that one perfect pull.
While nostalgia has its merits and while your story has its own quirks and unique settings, all you have done is describe exactly how any independent person discovers this card game. However, I appreciate your narrative and writing style and I hope to hear more stories from you about Magic: The Gathering!
The point I was trying to make was that my life was improved when I realized MTG’s value, specifically when I stopped seeing it as a nerdy thing to avoid. I only wish I had started playing earlier in my life! I really didn’t get serious until the Innistrad block, and I might write about playing against some national champs (spoiler: I did not win).
hey, don’t bring Bowie into it!
But Bowie IS in it!
@IOvUF Bowie loved the misfits and the geeks and the weirdos. He’s THE MOST in it!
That’s very depressing
When I was about 8 my uncle bought my this incredibly impressive MTG boxed set. I had no idea what it was, my parents had no idea what it was, and none of my friends played anything like that. It came with a ton of cards, a board, differently color gems for life. But it all looked, well, weird and foreign. My mom looked at it, and knowing my uncle was into some weird stuff, told me I couldn’t play with it. That was just fine by eight-year-old me, who didn’t understand how a card game could compete with video games.
Fast forward two years when I met some slightly older kids that played Magic: The Gathering. I got some money to buy a starter deck and some extra cards and after a few months of playing I remembered somewhere buried in my closet I had a whole bunch of cards! My mother had no idea where it went and we were never able to find it anywhere.
Every so often I think about that stupid set (I think it was 1993, which was around when the game first launched I think) and how it probably would be worth some money. I’m going to creep over to my grandmother’s apartment one day and rummage through her closets to see if it’s still buried in there somewhere.
Man, let me know if you find it. That sounds amazing.