“I could stand in the middle of 5th Avenue and shoot somebody and I wouldn’t lose voters.”
Ten years from now, we’ll look back on this line from Darrell Hammond’s Saturday Night Live version of Donald Trump the same way we look at Tina Fey’s now-iconic, “I can see Russia from my house.” And the way Hammond delivered the line was perfect. With that smushed face and cocksure smile, Hammond provided such great comedic timing, the studio audience inside 8H broke into applause. It works because it’s an outlandish version of the real Trump. Trump might think he could “shoot somebody” in Midtown Manhattan and not lose votes, but he certainly would never say it.
Only none of that is true. Donald Trump really did say that and we all kind of think it’s normal now – and how in the world is SNL supposed to parody that?
Thank goodness for Larry David’s Bernie Sanders, Kate McKinnon’s Hillary Clinton, and Jay Pharoah’s Ben Carson – the saving graces of SNL’s political humor this season. (And, thankfully, David will be hosting this week.) The Democratic primary is kind of, sort of working like most political primaries work. Ergo, Saturday Night Live has found good humor on the normal side of the aisle, because the show has done this sort of thing for 41 years and is pretty darn good at it.
The problem is, it’s the Republican side that’s getting most of the attention and SNL’s satire has been, frankly, pretty bad. Though, to be fair, it’s not really their fault because, again, how do you parody this?
This has been, quietly, a really good season of Saturday Night Live. I say “quietly” for a couple of reasons: Letting Trump host earlier this season led to a backlash against the show that wasn’t at all fair to the performers and writers. They have nothing to do with the talent bookings and just have to do the best with the hand they’ve been given. The other is that, yes, the political sketches – the bread and butter of the show every four years – have been (apart from Sanders, Clinton and Carson) in complete disarray.
The problem might not be as bad if we didn’t sense the show was panicking, but the musical chairs this season surrounding who is playing whom is not helping.
SNL made a big deal before the season started when they announced Taran Killam would be playing Donald Trump. SNL wanted this to be news. From what I understand, this was a hotly contested role and after tryouts, Killam narrowly edged out Beck Bennett. Killam wasn’t given much of a shot, as his first time was a poorly conceived cold open on the season premiere and his second appearance was up against Hammond’s Trump and the real Trump … which pretty much negated Killam’s Trump from the start. (Putting Killam next to the real Trump, in only Killam’s second ever time as Trump, was a huge mistake and was really unfair to Killam.)