Keegan-Michael Key and Jordan Peele’s Keanu hits theaters this Friday and it’s the first time since last September that a fortunate American public will get to see one of the best comedic duos of our time reunite in a meaningful way. But before you head down to your local theater to watch this chronicle about a missing cat (truly the star of the show), consider this: There’s been a hole in our hearts since Key & Peele ended, and the only way to fill it is with more films starring the pair. But should the two, who are working on a reboot of Police Academy, star in a brand new movie or should they resurrect an old favorite that the world’s been dying to see redone? If it’s the latter (why not both, though?) then we’ve got just a few ideas of exactly which buddy films Keegan-Michael Key and Jordan Peele could take on as their next project.