At Tuesday evening’s CNN Democratic Debate, Anderson Cooper tossed the mic over to Don Lemon, who presented “the question that has tripped some of the candidates out on the campaign trail.” Lemon’s presentation of such issues can be spotty, but he toned down the editorializing and allowed the question to stand: “Do Black Lives Matter or All Lives Matter?”
Bernie Sanders answered first with an immediate and unequivocal statement. Sanders has previously been met with friction from Black Lives Matter activists, so his answer was highly anticipated. His first sentence was met with applause. He continued to more punctuated claps from the audience.
“Black lives matter. And the reason those words matter is the African American community knows that on any given day, some innocent person like Sandra Bland can get into a car. And then three days later, she can end up dead in jail. Or their kids are gonna get shot. We need to combat institutional racism from top to bottom, and we need major, major reform in a broken criminal justice system in which we have more people in jail in China. And I intend to tackle that issue to make sure our people have education and jobs rather than jail cells.”
After all the candidates answered, Twitter ruled on how well the debate handled the subject. Some were simply happy the question was asked while others remained skeptical:
#BlackLivesMatter was a question in the #DemDebate. That's the power of direct action and grassroots activism. Word.
— Dallas Goldtooth (@dallasgoldtooth) October 14, 2015
Only black lives matter, say a bunch of rich old white folks pandering to minority voters.
— Ben Shapiro (@benshapiro) October 14, 2015
This ain't nothing but the sloganizing of #BlackLivesMatter at the #DemDebate
— Felonious Monk (@jkameroncarter) October 14, 2015
Bernie Sanders was largely praised for his consideration of the issue.
https://twitter.com/illuminiah/status/654114274122448896
"Sanders has come a very long way since the first time he was asked about #BlackLivesMatter" http://t.co/5kIJJQ5CFW pic.twitter.com/DtIxC8NMpc
— The New York Times (@nytimes) October 14, 2015
Bernie said BLACK LIVES MATTER. ✊
— G (@Msminxalot) October 14, 2015
Hillary Clinton also received a positive response, but Jim Webb didn’t score nearly as well as Sanders or Clinton:
Hillary do #BlackLivesMatter ??
— Mark Ruffalo (@MarkRuffalo) October 14, 2015
Clinton didn't have to answer the "do all lives matter or do black lives matter" question.
— Shirley Henry (@shirleyhenrydc) October 14, 2015
https://twitter.com/emmavandyke_/status/654115384463900673
Jim Webb doesn't understand #BlackLivesMatter. Or perhaps he is just too drunk to really understand the question. #DemDebate
— Not Bill Walton (@NotBillWalton) October 14, 2015
Several tweeters noticed that the answers didn’t go deep enough, and some candidates have revised their stance over the past few months:
Only took an hour for #BlackLivesMatter to come up. #DemDebate
— Miki Pope (@MikiTakesPhotos) October 14, 2015
Wait when did we move on from #BlackLivesMatter? Well that was short-lived. #DemDebate
— Christina Coleman Mullen (@ChrissyCole) October 14, 2015
Bummed we're done w black lives matter
— Clara Stanton (@clarastanton) October 14, 2015
Sanders, Clinton & O'Malley, months ago, all went with the "all lives matter" answer when they first encountered "Black Lives Matter" mvment
— Chuck Todd (@chucktodd) October 14, 2015